Is the Mortgage Stress Test on the Way Out?
 August 7 2025     Posted by Roar Admin

Is the Mortgage Stress Test on the Way Out? How OSFI's New Loan-to-Income Rules Could Reshape Borrowing in 2025-26

Canadian borrowers have spent the past seven years living with the mortgage "stress test," a rule that forces buyers and refinancers to qualify at the greater of 5.25 percent or two percentage points above their contract rate. That buffer protected households when rates were cheap, but in today's higher-rate world it is under fresh scrutiny. In June, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, OSFI, signalled it could replace that test with a loan-to-income, LTI, framework capped at 4.5 times a borrower's gross income. The change could land as early as 2026, and every Canadian with a mortgage decision on the horizon needs to understand the potential fallout.

1. From Interest-Rate Buffer to Income-Based Cap

Under the proposed rules lenders would monitor the share of new uninsured mortgages that exceed the 4.5× income cap, rather than forcing every applicant to clear a universal stress-test rate. The cap already applies at the portfolio level for federally regulated lenders beginning in fiscal 2025, giving OSFI real-world data before it makes a final decision on whether to scrap the stress test entirely.

OSFI says it will evaluate the framework until at least January 2026, then decide whether the LTI limit will stand alone or work alongside a scaled-back stress test. That timeline means borrowers shopping for pre-approvals in late 2025 could become the first to feel the impact.

2. A Perfect Storm of Renewals and Rate Plateau

The Bank of Canada held its overnight rate steady at 2.75 percent on July 30, 2025, its second consecutive hold. While stability offers short-term relief, a massive renewal wave means roughly 60 percent of all outstanding mortgages will reset between now and the end of 2026, most of them at higher rates.

The central bank's own modelling shows that about 60 percent of those renewing will still see payment increases, averaging 10 percent in 2025 and 6 percent in 2026 even if rates remain flat. In other words, qualification rules and payment affordability are converging issues for many households.

3. Who Stands to Benefit, and Who Could Be Squeezed?

• First-time buyers: High-income earners with modest down payments may qualify for larger mortgages under a pure LTI test because their household income, rather than the stress-test rate, becomes the ceiling.
• Move-up buyers in expensive markets: Households relying on two strong incomes could find that the 4.5× cap still limits purchasing power, especially in Greater Vancouver and the GTA, where median price-to-income ratios already exceed 10×.
• Renewers with growing salaries: If OSFI moves to LTI only, borrowers whose income has risen since 2020 could refinance into competitive rates without clearing an artificially high qualifying rate.
• Self-employed borrowers: Stated-income files could face extra scrutiny because actual taxable income, not gross revenue, will be the LTI denominator.

4. Stress Test vs. LTI: A Quick Scenario

Consider a couple earning a combined $150,000, seeking a five-year fixed mortgage at 4.69 percent with a 25-year amortization and 20 percent down.

• Current stress test: Must qualify at the greater of 5.25 percent or 6.69 percent. At 6.69 percent the maximum mortgage is roughly $560,000, translating to a purchase price near $700,000.
• Proposed LTI at 4.5×: Maximum mortgage is $675,000 (4.5 × $150,000), allowing a purchase price closer to $845,000 with the same down payment.

For borrowers on the cusp of qualifying, the difference can be the gap between condo and townhouse, or townhouse and detached home. Note, however, that lenders must keep their overall portfolio within OSFI's limits, so not every applicant will receive the higher ceiling.

5. Could Home Prices Rise or Fall?

Economists are split. Some argue that income-based caps in markets like the United Kingdom cooled demand and discouraged speculative bidding, implying price softness is possible. Others warn that if the LTI becomes the sole test and rates decline modestly, latent demand from sidelined buyers could spark renewed price pressure in mid-2026.

In the short term, expect a flurry of purchases before any transition date, as borrowers rush to lock in stress-test-based approvals. Similar surges occurred in 2016 before insured- versus uninsured-loan rule changes and again in 2018 when OSFI first introduced the stress test for conventional mortgages.

6. What You Should Do Between Now and 2026

• Run an income stress test today: Calculate your current LTI and debt-service ratios to see how close you already are to 4.5× income.
• Secure early rate holds: Lenders can typically lock a rate for 90–120 days. Doing so now protects you if rates slip lower but the stress-test rule remains.
• Consider a refinance check-up: If you renew in 2025-26, gather current pay stubs, T1s, and a property valuation so your broker can model both stress-test and LTI scenarios the moment rules change.
• Boost your credit buffers: Pay down credit cards and lines of credit. A lower total debt service ratio gives you more wiggle room under either framework.
• Stay informed: OSFI's next formal update is expected after its December 2025 meetings, with a possible implementation date in early 2026. Revisit your pre-approval strategy once new guidance is published.

7. Our Commitment to You

Navigating regulatory change is exactly where an experienced broker adds value. We monitor OSFI updates, Bank of Canada releases, and lender policy memos daily so you do not have to. When the rules shift, our team will re-underwrite your file under both regimes and advise on timing your application for maximum borrowing power, or maximum safety, depending on your goals.

Whether you are buying your first home, moving up, or facing renewal anxiety, reach out for a personalized assessment. We will map out best-case, base-case, and worst-case payment projections, factoring in potential LTI caps, future rate moves, and your household budget.

Bottom Line

The mortgage stress test is not gone yet, but Canada's shift toward an income-based framework is well under way. The window to optimize your borrowing strategy under the current rules is measured in months, not years. Proactive planning today can save thousands in interest tomorrow and put you in a stronger negotiating position when OSFI makes its final call in 2026.

Ready to see where you stand? Book a discovery call or apply online for a no-obligation pre-approval and stress-test check-up. Together, we will make sure policy changes work for you, not against you.